| First Team All-USA South Athletic Conference |
| Year |
Player (Seed) |
| 1968 |
Hal Johnson (No. 5) |
| 1971 |
Vaughn John (No. 1) |
| 1972 |
Vaughn John (No. 1) |
| 1990 |
Jonathan Terry-Tom Maze (No. 2) |
| 1991 |
Jim Lavender (No. 3), Jeff Hawes (No. 4), Jonathan Terry (No. 5), Jonathan Terry-Jeff Hawes (No. 2) |
|
Mark Faber-Scott Pickrel (No. 3) |
| 1992 |
Jonathan Terry (No. 4), Mark Faber (No. 5), Matt Hill (No. 6), Chip Collins-Chris Collins (No. 1), Jeff |
|
Hawes-Mark Faber (No. 2), Jonathan Terry-Matt Hill (No. 3) |
| 1993 |
Wade Liles (No. 2), Foo Kong (No. 3), Marc Tyndale (No. 5), Foo Kong-Wade Liles (No. 2) |
| 1994 |
David Wood (No. 3), Doug Tingle (No. 6), Mark Faber-Wade Liles (No. 1), David Wood-Brian Clary |
|
(No. 2) |
| 1995 |
Scott Jenkin (No. 2), Joe Baile (No. 6), Jeremy Plumley-Terry Sellars (No. 2), Joe Baile-Alex |
|
Proctor-Pearson (No. 3) |
| 1997 |
Scott Jenkin (No. 2), Jon Bennett (No. 5), Joe Baile (No. 6), Telly Sellars-Jon Bennett (No. 2), |
|
Jason Brown-Doug Tingle (No. 3) |
| 1998 |
Scott Jenkin-Nick Saltmarsh (No. 1) |
| 1999 |
Andrew Ummel (No. 5), Chad McCall-Andrew Ummel (No. 3) |
| 2001 |
Stephen Quillevere (No. 5). Kevin Caccia (No. 6), Adam Hunter-Joshua Obermeyer (No. 2) |
| 2002 |
Glen Kitner (No. 1), Kevin Caccia (No. 5), Marcus Dudley (No. 6), Kevin Caccia-Ben Porter (No. 3) |
| 2003 |
Ben Porter (No. 4), Ben Porter-Marcus Dudley (No. 3) |
| 2004 |
Keith Criscoe (No. 2), Kevin Criscoe (No. 3), Ben Porter (No. 4), Adam Hunter-Ben Porter (No. 2) |
| 2005 |
Keith Criscoe, Chris Fletcher |
| 2006 |
Keith Criscoe, Chris Fletcher |
| 2007 |
Chris Fletcher |
| 2008 |
Chris Fletcher |
| 2010 |
Matthew Taylor |
| 2011 |
Matthew Taylor |
| 2013 |
Duncan Miller |
| 2014 |
Taylor Buchholz, Duncan Miller |
| 2015 |
R.J. Clement |
| 2016 |
Taylor Buchholz, R.J. Clement |
| 2017 |
R.J. Clement |
| 2018 |
R.J. Clement |
| 2019 |
Coleman Baker, Trent Harner, Wynn Johnson |
| 2021 |
Jordan Theron, Trent Harner |
| 2022 |
Jordan Theron |
| 2023 |
Wills Belser, Matthew Hurley |
| 2024 |
Matthew Hurley |
| Second Team All-USA South Athletic Conference |
| Year |
Player (Seed) |
| 1999 |
Nick Saltmarsh (No. 1), Chad McCall (No. 6) |
| 2000 |
Shawn D'Oliviera (No. 3), Ryan Beals-Goncalo Marques (No. 2) |
| 2001 |
Kevin Criscoe (No. 2), Adam Hunter (No. 3), Marcus Dudley (No. 4), Kevin Caccia-Kevin Criscoe |
|
(No. 3) |
| 2002 |
Adam Hunter (No. 2), Kevin Criscoe (No. 3), Ben Porter (No. 4), Adam Hunter-Keith Kassouf |
|
(No. 2), Kevin Criscoe-Glen Kitner (No. 2) |
| 2003 |
Adam Hunter (No. 1), Glen Kitner (No. 2), Marcus Dudley (No. 6), Adam Hunter-Glen Kitner (No. 1) |
|
Kevin Caccia-Kevin Criscoe (No. 2) |
| 2004 |
Adam Hunter (No. 1), Mark Ryman (No. 6), Keith Criscoe-Kevin Criscoe (No. 1), Lowell Fischer- |
|
Mark Ryman (No. 3) |
| 2005 |
David Hardy |
| 2006 |
Matthew Siegel |
| 2007 |
Andrew Freeman, David Hardy |
| 2008 |
Dylan Knox |
| 2009 |
Matthew Taylor |
| 2011 |
Duncan Miller |
| 2012 |
Hans Baumstark, Duncan Miller |
| 2013 |
Taylor Buchholz, Greg Patterson |
| 2014 |
Greg Patterson |
| 2015 |
Taylor Buchholz |
| 2016 |
Teal Howard |
| 2017 |
John Dangerfield |
| 2018 |
Coleman Baker, Trent Harner |
| 2022 |
Quinn McNamara, Henry Murray |
| 2024 |
Wills Belser, Harry Crokam |
|
Third Team All-USA South Athletic Conference
|
| Year |
Player |
| 2014 |
Max Mancini, Dillon Sullivan |
| Honorable Mention All-USA South Athletic Conference |
| Year |
Player (Seed) |
| 2005 |
Mike Layton |
| 2007 |
Mike Layton, Matthew Siegel |
| 2008 |
Jarrod Bogard |
| 2009 |
Dylan Knox, Rob Schmidt |
| 2010 |
Robert Clayton |
| 2012 |
Robert Clayton, Greg Patterson, Austin Wang |
| 2013 |
Teal Howard, Lawrence Salmon, Dillon Sullivan |
| 2021 |
Coleman Baker |
